Throughout the history of mankind there have been countless polarizing issues that have caused rifts between countries. Right now we are having one of those rifts yet again. Race is always a hot button topic in America and, in the foreseen future, always will be. A terroristic mass murder has brought about an old debate over the Confederate Battle Flag. It’s a topic of conversation that tries to make one choose a side when discussed; even if you personally have no side. If you try to stay neutral, then each side will plead their cases. Don’t agree with their views? Then you are racist or not truly from the South. Both sides of the argument could stand to gain tolerance for the other as well as a reminder of the histories behind the flag.
The Confederacy is no longer a threat to America, and that is because it no longer exists. You will have groups such as the Daughters of the Confederacy, but they are not going to rise up and cause states to secede again. Most defenders of the flag have the romantic image of the battle flag from old movies, pop culture in the 80’s, NASCAR, or their favorite t-shirt. Humans tend to repress unwanted memories of times that were “undesirable” and they cling to the more rebellious ideals the flag once stood for. Many opposing the flag still remember fearing the KKK and the race riots that used the Confederate Flag as a banner. Tormented by burning crosses and racism in this country. This flag has changed numerous times as a symbol and each side holds on to one or the other. Anyone that defends the flag cannot forget what oppression came with this symbol of hate and white supremacy.
To those opposed to the flag: the Civil War was not completely about freeing the slaves. If that were true, then why were northern states allowed to keep their slaves even after the Emancipation Proclamation? Almost everyone was racist during the Civil War and not just the southern states. The evil Robert E. Lee was actually recruited by the north at the beginning of the war, but because of the idea that your state was your nation he made the hard decision to stay with Virginia. It is even suggested that he opposed slavery. The truly malicious intent of the symbol came from when the KKK used it during the 50’s and 60’s. One cannot discount someone’s argument that it stands for rebelliousness or southern pride based on one group’s use of the flag. Yes, horrible atrosities have occurred in the past and racism still exists today, but not everyone hold the same stereotypical views that come with the flag.
Tolerance and understanding should be a two way street in my opinion. Many have compared the Confederate Flag to the Nazi swastika. I believe this is a fairly accurate comparison. For thousands of years Buddhism and Hinduism have used the swastika as a symbol of good fortune. Hitler adopted and adjusted the image in hopes of good fortune to come to his troops. My comparison of the two stems from this idea that we are letting one group or one isolated instance to define a single symbol that means so much more than a single ideal.
“ELE! Everybody love everybody!”
-Jackie Moon, Semi Pro 2008